Expanding Conquest, Warning “Punishments”

After dispatching reinforcements to Fort Santo Tomás, Columbus decided on the next steps to his conquest of “Española.” Alonso de Hojeda would replace Pedro Margarite as the fort’s warden, and Margarite was to march about the island with a squadron of almost four...

Frictions Mount

Columbus returned to Isabela in late March 1494, having left Pedro Margarite and a garrison of almost sixty men in the island’s mountainous Cibao to complete Fort Santo Tomás’s construction (see post of March 12). Within just days—April 1, 1494 (528 years...

Fate of First Indigenous Captives Sent to Spain

The twelve ships Columbus had dispatched to Spain from Isabela on February 2, 1494 (see post of February 2), arrived Cádiz on March 7, and the surviving indigenous captives he’d taken on Guadeloupe and St. Croix (see posts of November 4 and 14) were transferred to the...

Fort Santo Tomás

With Isabela’s construction underway on the coast, on March 12, 1494 (528 years ago), Columbus heralded his conquest of “Española,” marching with five hundred men into the mountainous region the Taínos called the Cibao to build a fort intended to garrison soldiers who...

Twilight Before Hostilities, First European Mutiny

The island’s Taíno chieftains scrutinized Isabela’s construction in early 1494 and the permanent presence apparently intended—but they didn’t attack. The chieftains then traded peacefully among themselves and with other peoples in the Caribbean (excepting Caribes),...